Why "Healing" Gut Issues with the Carnivore Diet is a Band-Aid Solution for most people.

Alright, let’s talk gut health. For anyone who's struggled with bloating, gas, or that constant sense of “Why did I eat that?!” when you’ve only had a few broccoli florets, the carnivore diet can sound like a dream come true. Meat and more meat. No bloating, no gas… just a happy gut, right?

Or is it?

It turns out that while the carnivore diet may give some quick relief, it might actually just be slapping a band-aid on a deeper issue without truly healing the gut from the inside out. Let’s dive into why that might be the case.

1. Symptom Suppression, Not Solution

Imagine the carnivore diet as putting the gut on airplane mode. It stops receiving all the typical “messages” from those trouble-causing foods (fiber, carbs, anything remotely plant-based). But here’s the kicker—it's not teaching the gut anything new; it’s just muting the problem. This can help for a while, sure, but if gut issues are a result of a deeper mind-body connection (like stress, emotions, or even how we handle life), the root of the issue isn’t addressed.

2. The Gut-Mind Connection (aka the mind-body connection/PPD/TMS

So much of what goes on in our gut isn’t just about the food itself but about how our brain and body are processing it. The gut and brain are super tight; they’re connected by the vagus nerve and are basically in constant communication. If the mind is stressed, tense, or stuck on repeat about something, the gut can feel it. That means chronic stress or emotions we’d rather not deal with—hello, suppressed rage—can sometimes manifest as gut problems.

For example, I've known people who feel their gut act up only on workdays. The weekend? Smooth sailing. When gut issues have deeper roots like this, eating just meat is like telling the gut, “Take five!” without really helping it process the true source of its stress.

3. Not a Long-Term Fix

One big issue with relying on a carnivore diet for gut health is that it’s really hard to reintroduce foods down the line without feeling the same symptoms all over again. It’s almost like taking a vacation from the problem without building any actual resilience while working on the deeper emotional cause.

To truly heal, the gut needs rest bite, not from fibre and other dietary "triggers", but from a brain in a persistent emotional flux (usually unconscious/subconscious. For long-lasting relief, people often have to do more than cut things out; they need to calm that gut-brain connection so the body feels safe and strong enough to handle whatever comes its way (yes, even that rebellious broccoli).

4. The Hypervigilance Trap

Here’s something that might sound familiar to anyone who’s been down the restricted-diet rabbit hole: hypervigilance. It’s that state where, no matter what you’re eating, you’re scanning every bite, every after-effect, waiting for any hint of trouble. This diet can be great for symptom control, but it also often makes people so focused on what they eat that they accidentally create even more stress around food.

When we address the mind-body connection, we’re not only calming the gut but giving the whole nervous system a breather, too. Focusing on stress management and emotional health can actually lower that hypervigilance and ease up the whole digestive process over time.

So, does the carnivore diet work for gut health? Sure, it can bring temporary relief. But if gut issues are cropping up due to stress or mind-body factors, then addressing those might be the ticket to true healing. Rather than a quick band-aid, it’s about building a resilient gut from the inside out.

And hey, if it means being able to enjoy a little bit of broccoli on the side again someday, it might be worth a shot!

Please let me know if you have any thoughts to share, or if you found this blog of interest.

Take care for now,

Duncan